Skip to main content

About Africa Realities Media

TNT paranoia over UK's Aid to Rwanda


Rwanda should reject this "food for work" from the UK

photo
Pan Butamire

When I heard that the United Kingdom had gone back on its pledge of channelling aid to Rwanda through the budget as general budget support, I was thrown back to the mid-1990s. Rwanda then was a darling of the West. All donor countries were falling over themselves, stuffing her with what went for aid. 

The country was an object of pity, having just emerged out of a near-abyss. For that, they sought to appease their conscience.

Problem was, though, there was that nothing to show for that aid, save for a multitude of humanitarian NGOs and their massive four-wheel-drive vehicles. Every part of Rwanda was teeming with swarms of these organisations and the monster vehicles, yet people lived in squalor. Hunger and disease stalked the land even as citizens trooped to the organisations for rations of food and medicine. The government and the organisations seemed to be locked in a tug of war, as the former struggled to wrest control of its citizens from the latter, while the country stagnated. 

Kinyinya and Nyarutarama, both upmarket suburban estates of Kigali today, provided a good example.

To reach them, you had to navigate the backbreaking, rugged track that led to Kagugu, further north. Past Nyarutarama, to your right you reached a smooth tarmac road that incomprehensibly sprang from the track, leading to Kinyinya. In Kinyinya sat a fortified, exclusive enclosure that housed the Deutsche Welle relay station. The enclosure, with its short strip of tarmac road, was an island of luxury in an empty wilderness, totally detached from its surroundings. 

On both sides of the rugged track and the smooth strip of a road that shot from it, haggard-looking citizens were bent over every day, cutting the tall savannah grass and shrubs that stubbornly resisted their feeble attempts. The hungry citizens were working for what was referred to as "food for work". 

This was not an isolated case. All over Rwanda, citizens were working for food, doing work that neither benefitted them nor built their country in any other way. It was literally a hand-to-mouth existence. Clearly, the relationship with the donor community portended a future that was bleak.

So, the government booted out all NGOs, leaving only those that gave meaningful assistance. It needed assistance, yes, but only it knew what areas needed to be assisted. That is how it came out strongly to campaign for general budget support from the donor countries. The campaign was long and drawn-out but eventually the donor community relented. 

Once the government was in full charge of its own development, transparently showing the donors where every penny went, the country took off at a speed that confounded friend and foe. By the early 2000s, even the donors could not hide their amazement at the spectacular growth the country was registering. Today, that growth is becoming faster by the day. Meanwhile, Rwandans have started to refer to donors as development partners, with the intention of wooing them for investment and finally doing away with their aid.

But a problem has been tugging at the heart strings of the donor community: the stubborn leadership of this country. Where every country that is aid-dependent kowtows to the donors, Rwanda obstinately sticks to its independent spirit, forever unwilling to answer to the fancy of these partners. And, rather than break this independent spirit, partnership seems to enhance it.

When you see the gymnastics donors are involved in, therefore, you should know that they are looking for a process that will break that spirit. 

The accusations of dictatorship and press-freedom suppression that have been with Rwanda since the late 1990s are in the service of this process. The UN accusations of genocide perpetration in D R Congo that failed to stick were an attempt at this. But the last chance came with the recent accusations of Rwanda's involvement in D R Congo's problems and they were seized upon even before they were confirmed.

Now the donors have got an excuse to wriggle themselves out of that partnership commitment and its back to "food for work". The UK says it will "provide cash grants or cash for work to the poorest". It will "supply textbooks and supplementary readers to primary and secondary school pupils" – discarded by their pupils, no doubt.  It will "provide emergency relief to refugees" – as if that will be assistance to Rwanda. It will set up "child development centres", "VSO support programmes"; it will this, it will that. All through NGOs. All blabbering baloney!

The government should put its foot down and reject a return of this "food for work". Those fat NGO employees and their fat drives, those islands of luxury unconnected to the citizenry, can go find employment elsewhere.


Contact email: Email: butapa[at]gmail.com Blog: butamire.wordpress.com

Comments

My man, you'll always be my fave columnist at this news organization. Let me quote your last line again: "Those fat NGO employees and their fat drives...can go find employment elsewhere". You're spot on brother.


 03:44:39 Friday 08th, March 2013 Sudbury, Ontario, Canada - Ntare Batinya Kayitare (101 Battalion Forever)

Reply | Close

That was spot on. This type of aid diverts us from our development path, it is unacceptable and must be rejected. Any aid should operate within the framework of EDPRS and the Govt has shown that it works as millions of people continue to emerge out of poverty.


 06:40:44 Friday 08th, March 2013 Kayonza - J Bideri

Reply | Close

Pat,

Couldn't be explained better. And your concluding paragraph reflects my views, perfectly.


 09:10:23 Friday 08th, March 2013 Jkalinda@gmail.com - Mwene Kalinda

Reply | Close

You are spot-on!!!!


 12:49:23 Friday 08th, March 2013 Kigali - Richard

Reply | Close

I am aware NGOs or Donors have had a bad reputation in international development but Hate them or not, they have done a great job in Rwanda!

Of course there are could have been dodgy NGOs, but dont tell me Donors or NGOs havent played a role in changing the face of development in this country!

Lets be honest as a people and stop trivialising issues because some Donors cut aid!I have worked for some NGOs and personally i knw how much i push in to contribute to the development of our people, so give us some credit.

Lastly instead of critising Donors, NGOs, lets encourage our people to work hard and stop waiting on aid, AId is not parmanent! Aid has never made anyone rich, if we want to become self sustaining,lets not wait on aid!


 13:08:35 Friday 08th, March 2013 Kigali - Gasana Grace

Reply | Close

Please, add "Dead Aid", a book by Dambisa Moyo. It clealy shows what the so-called "Aid" is about.


 13:19:00 Friday 08th, March 2013 France - Manzi

Reply | Close

Submit your comment

:
:
:
Please type the answerWhat is : 5 + 2 

Comments

Support Our Work Now !

Africa Realities Media is independent. Your support helps us expose injustice, challenge silence and produce evidence-based analysis on Africa and the Great Lakes Region.
Africa Realities Media offre un espace aux écrivains, chercheurs, experts, activistes, voix communautaires, militants, analystes et personnes ayant une expérience vécue qui souhaitent contribuer à des contenus réfléchis, responsables et courageux sur les changements nécessaires dans la région des Grands Lacs, ainsi que sur les réalités politiques, économiques, culturelles et sociales africaines souvent ignorées, minimisées ou mal représentées. Nos articles et vidéos visent à ouvrir le débat, renforcer la sensibilisation, encourager la pensée critique et favoriser une réflexion plus profonde sur les réalités vécues par les populations africaines. Nous voulons aider les peuples de la région des Grands Lacs à mieux comprendre leurs droits, notamment leurs droits humains, leur droit au développement, leur droit à la dignité, à la sécurité, au bien-être et à une vie meilleure. À travers nos contenus, nous cherchons également à rappeler aux décideurs, aux institutions publiques, aux acteurs régionaux et internationaux, ainsi qu’aux responsables politiques, leur devoir de transparence, de responsabilité et de redevabilité envers les populations qu’ils prétendent servir. Notre objectif est de contribuer à une culture de vérité, de justice, de participation citoyenne et de protection égale pour tous les peuples africains.

Why We Exist

Many abuses facing African people are committed by African states, ruling elites, armed groups, military forces and security services. But these abuses are often sustained by international silence, Western lobbying, trade interests, migration deals, mineral access, diplomatic partnerships and unequal global accountability. Africa Realities Media exposes that system.

Lived Experience Matters

Survivors, displaced communities, refugees, families affected by repression, journalists, activists, women, young people and diaspora voices are not passive subjects. They are knowledge holders. Their experiences must shape policy, advocacy, journalism and public debate. The people closest to injustice are often closest to the solutions.

Our Principle

Africa Realities Media is rooted in one principle: African lives deserve equal truth, equal justice and equal protection.

Popular Posts

Pourquoi la politique africaine du Président Macron, centrée sur le Rwanda, n’a pas porté ses fruits

Le Président Emmanuel Macron a passé neuf ans à faire la paix avec Paul Kagame et, pendant ce temps, la France a perdu presque tout le reste de ce qu’elle avait en Afrique. Les vies africaines ne valent pas moins. Les morts africaines ne sont pas normales. Les intérêts occidentaux ne doivent jamais devenir un permis de tuer des Africains. Introduction : une réconciliation bâtie sur une seule relation Lorsqu’Emmanuel Macron arrive à l’Élysée en mai 2017, il promet de refonder la relation entre la France et l’Afrique. Six mois plus tard, devant les étudiants de Ouagadougou, il annonce à tout un continent la fin de la Françafrique. Neuf ans après, le bilan est sans appel. La France n’a plus aucune base militaire permanente en Afrique de l’Ouest ni en Afrique centrale, trois gouvernements du Sahel boycottent ses sommets, et les manifestations antifrançaises font désormais partie du paysage politique, de Bamako à Kinshasa. Au cœur de la diplomatie africaine d’Emmanuel Macro...

Disgusting Reports On How African & Indonesian Women Dry Their VAGINA With Sand & Bleach To Make Sex Pleasurable For Men

Share 64   3   Share 3   1   Tweet 64 Women mostly in South and Central Africa, and Indonesia are carrying out a horrific practice known as  ‘ Dry Sex’  which not only leaves them in pain but at increased risk of HIV.  Dailymail  Report Dry sex is a practice where women reduce moisture in their vaginas in order to make intercourse more pleasurable for men. This according to reports can lead to cuts, sores and inflammation in the vagina, and increases the chance of a condom breaking. These factors in turn increase the chance of the women contracting sexually transmitted diseases including HIV. It is borne out of a cultural belief that men find sex more pleasurable if a woman’s vagina is dry, and that men will reject women whose vaginas have been  ‘stretched out’  by sex. To achieve dryness, women insert, chalk, sand, pulverized rock, herbs, paper or sponges before sex, according to journalist Ms Syfret, who has reported o...

Somaliland's Independence and International Law: A Response to Professor Abdi Ismail Samatar

Legal Realism, Sovereignty and the Pan-African Future By Saeed Mohamed Ahmed (Surwaale Jr.) Opinion and Analysis | Africa Realities Media Abstract This article examines Somaliland's claim to sovereignty through international law, constitutional history, democratic self-determination and the political experience of state-building in the Horn of Africa. It responds to Professor Abdi Ismail Samatar's criticisms of Somaliland's independence movement, particularly his characterisation of the project as sectarian and his comparison with apartheid-era Bantustans. The discussion follows an exchange published by Pambazuka News in July 2026, beginning with Samatar's Caged Somalia: Can it be Liberated from a Demonic Elite? , followed by my response, The Mogadishu Blind Spot , and Samatar's subsequent rejoinder, Sectarian Navel-gazing Framework is Oxymoronic to Somali & African Ambitions . Drawing on the scholarship of Paolo Contini, Eugene Cotran, Hussein...

Fw: [uRwanda_rwacu] US, UK Want Review of “1994 Genocide Against the Tutsi” Appellation – THE CHRONICLES | Rwanda

  https://www.chronicles.rw/2020/05/26/us-uk-want-review-of-1994-genocide-against-the-tutsi-appellation/ US, UK Want Review of "1994 Genocide Against the Tutsi" Appellation Chronicles Team UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and US President Donald Trump during the latter's visit in London In a rare shift of policy, both the United States and the United Kingdom are fiercely opposed to referencing the genocide which took place in Rwanda in 1994 as "1994 genocide against the Tutsi", according to documents only emerging now. The US and UK also accuse government of Rwanda of attempting to "force" its desires on the international community. In response, Rwanda also accuses both countries of "distorting" facts about the genocide. The letters from all sides about the issue give a rare insight into a long political fight that seems to be getting underway. ...

Nous ne sommes pas égaux face au coronavirus

Voir cet email dans votre navigateur Bonjour Realities RFI est pleinement mobilisé pour vous informer sur le Covid-19, ses impacts et vous apporter des éléments de compréhension sur la pandémie. Disparités et inégalités face au coronavirus SARS-CoV-2: ce qu'il faut retenir Coronavirus: Chine, du déni à la pandémie Coronavirus: dépistage à dimension variable Washington affirme que le remdesivir agit contre le coronavirus Madagascar: des dons de Covid-Organics pour certains pays africains «L'Afrique n'est pas à l'abri», selon les Nations unies Le voyage sans retour des expatriés sénégalais décédés du Covid-19 L'Afrique teste l'impression 3D dans le combat contre le Covid-19 Comment le coronavirus chamboule le trafic de drogue StopCovid: quelle efficacité pour l'application de traçage voulue par le gouvernement? Experience Meccah, une visite virtuelle de La Mecque faute de pèlerinage   La grippe de Hong Kong, première pandémie moderne   Pour découvrir tous nos...

La chauve-souris, l’héroïne du coronavirus

Voir cet email dans votre navigateur Bonjour Realities RFI est pleinement mobilisé pour vous informer sur le Covid-19, ses impacts et vous apporter des éléments de compréhension sur la pandémie. La chauve-souris, l'héroïne du coronavirus Coronavirus: anticorps et immunité, le point sur la recherche   Antonio Guterres sur RFI: un vaccin contre le Covid-19 devra être «un bien public global» David Malpass (Banque mondiale) sur RFI: «Nous cherchons à élargir le moratoire sur la dette» Coronavirus : la riposte des institutions africaines Le confinement a fait chuter les émissions de CO2 dans le monde Déconfinement en Oklahoma: le réveil difficile Le coronavirus maintient la tendance haussière des cours de l'or Le coronavirus va-t-il modifier les habitudes alimentaires en Chine? Télétravail, le nouvel horizon de l'entreprise? La BNF conserve la mémoire du coronavirus sur le Web   Le business du foot africain à l'arrêt Pour découvrir tous nos contenus sur le coronavirus, cliq...

Fw: *DHR* Fw: Kabuga

  "Loin d'être une patate chaude comme l'écrit Médiapart, c'est plutôt une bonne occasion pour que ce tribunal redore son blason. Je formule un vœu solennel « que le jugement de Félicien Kabuga soit un jugement pour l'histoire»! Affaire Félicien Kabuga. Quand la justice internationale se met à l'épreuve! By  Jean Claude Ndungutse  on May 28, 2020 share 95   chat_bubble_outline 3 Login Login Dans l'histoire des affaires judiciaires, dans la majorité des cas, justice est rendue mais parfois dans bien d'autres, on assiste à des fiascos, à des affaires non élucidées, à des erreurs et/ou à des parodies de justice. Cela a toujours existé et existera encore et toujours. Pour une raison simple : c'est la justice des hommes et « là où il y a de l'homme, il y a de l'hommerie », disait Saint François de Sales. Il y a des erreurs et des affaires non-élucidées, disais-...

Madame KABUGA,Waterloo: Quand des forces de sécurité ne respectent pas le deuil d’une famille

Madame KABUGA,Waterloo: Quand des forces de sécurité ne respectent pas le deuil d'une famille Madame KABUGA,Waterloo: Quand des forces de sécurité ne respectent pas le deuil d'une famille – LeRwandais Madame KABUGA,Waterloo: Quand des forces de sécurité ne respectent pas l... therwda 3 ans ago Madame Josephine Mukazitoni Kabuga Madame Joséphine Mukazitoni  est décédée le 03 février 2017.  Elle fut enterrée à Waterloo le samedi 11 février 2017. Elle avait 75 ans. Voir pièces jointes (la carte-souvenir recto-verso) Précisons que feu Madame Joséphine Mukazitoni est l'épouse de Félicien Kabuga  ancien homme d'affaires rwandais d'avant 1994. Félicien Kabuga était un proche de l'ancien président Habyarimana par alliance.  Aussi, après l'assassinat du président Habyarimana, les massacres qui ont suivi et la prise du pouvoir par le FPR, Félicien Kabuga s'exila comme presque tous les dignitaires hutus de l'ancien régime. Dès la création du Tribunal Pénal Inte...

Fw: [uRwanda_rwacu] Re: US, UK Want Review of “1994 Genocide Against the Tutsi” Appellation – THE CHRONICLES | Rwanda [1 Attachment]

Explanation of Position on the UN General Assembly Resolution on the Rwandan Genocide Home  |  |  Explanation of Position on the UN General Assembly Resolution on the Rwandan Genocide Ambassador Kelly Craft Permanent Representative U.S. Mission to the United Nations New York, New York April 23, 2020 Explanation of Position on the UN General Assembly Resolution on the Rwandan Genocide Since the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda and the establishment in 2003 of the "International Day of Reflection on the Genocide in Rwanda," April 7 has become a solemn day to commemorate the more than 800,000 men, women, and children whose lives were lost during 100 days of unspeakable violence.    The United States joins consensus with the entire UN General Assembly to support the continuation of this "International Day of Reflection on the 1994 Genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda" so that each year, we may continue to honor the victims and the survivors who carry the memories o...

Arrestation de Félicien Kabuga. Historique d’un dossier judiciaire controversé

Back Archive Move Delete Spam [fondationbanyarwanda] Arrestation de Félicien Kabuga. Historique d’un dossier judiciaire controversé – Echos d'Afrique 2 Yahoo / Inbox Nzinink nzinink@yahoo.com [fondationbanyarwanda]  <fondationbanyarwanda@yahoogroupes.fr> Unsubscribe To: nzinink@yahoo.com Mon, 18 May at 02:08 http://www.echosdafrique.com/20200517-arrestation-de-felicien-kabuga-historique-dun-dossier-judiciaire-controverse Arrestation de Félicien Kabuga. Historique d’un dossier judiciaire controversé Jean-Charles Murego L’arrestation de Félicien Kabuga, le 16/5/2020 à Paris, a fait la Une de bon nombre de journaux du monde et la nouvelle est partagée abondamment sur les réseaux sociaux. Mis en accusation il y a un quart de siècle, les charges qui pèsent sur Kabuga Félicien se sont peu à peu effondrés et le dossier judiciaire s’est dégonflé au vu des éléments nouveaux apparus au tout au long de ces 25 ans et qui permettent d’éclaircir certaines zones d’ombre du génocide rwandais...

Why Africa Realities Media Is Different

Africa Realities Media speaks to Africa and to the developed world. Many abuses facing African people are committed by African states and ruling elites, but they are often protected by international silence, lobbying, public relations, trade interests, migration deals and unequal global accountability. While governments pay lobbyists to present a good image abroad, ordinary African people continue to face violence, hunger, disease, poverty, repression and exclusion. We challenge the normalisation of African suffering and demand equal truth, equal justice and equal protection.

Pourquoi Africa Realities Media est différent?

Africa Realities Media s’adresse à l’Afrique et au monde développé. De nombreux abus subis par les peuples africains sont commis par des États africains et des élites dirigeantes, mais ils sont souvent protégés par le silence international, le lobbying, les relations publiques, les intérêts commerciaux, les accords migratoires et une responsabilité mondiale inégale. Tandis que des gouvernements paient des lobbyistes pour présenter une bonne image à l’étranger, des Africains ordinaires continuent de faire face à la violence, à la faim, aux maladies, à la pauvreté, à la répression et à l’exclusion. Nous contestons la normalisation de la souffrance africaine et exigeons une vérité égale, une justice égale et une protection égale.

BBC News

Policy and Systems Change

Our work is designed to trigger debate, discomfort and action. We do not only expose injustice; we work for policy and systems change. We want governments and institutions to address the root causes of inequality, disadvantage, discrimination, exclusion and barriers affecting African people. We believe lasting change must be shaped by people with lived experience.

Exposing Injustice in Africa

Africa Realities Media is an independent African accountability platform based in London. We report, analyse and challenge the systems that shape African suffering, silence African victims and protect abusive power. We are not here to repeat diplomatic language. We are here to ask the questions that are often avoided: why are African deaths treated as normal? Why are African victims given less urgency? Why are governments that imprison, exclude, displace or kill their own people protected when they serve powerful international interests?

Africanews

Africa Realities Media gives space to writers, researchers, experts, activists, community voices, campaigners, analysts and people with lived experience who want to contribute thoughtful, responsible and courageous content about the changes needed in the region, as well as the political, economic, cultural and social African realities that are often ignored, minimised or misrepresented. Our articles and videos aim to encourage debate, raise awareness, stimulate critical thinking and support reflection. We seek to help people in the Great Lakes Region understand their rights to human rights, development and wellbeing, while also encouraging decision-makers to be more transparent, responsive and accountable.

Recent Posts

Appel à contributions

Sensibilisez le public aux causes qui vous tiennent à cœur. Prenez part au changement que vous souhaitez voir émerger. Aidez à combattre l'injustice partout où elle se manifeste.

Africa Realities Media accueille des articles originaux, analyses, tribunes, réflexions communautaires et commentaires fondés sur des faits concernant la région des Grands Lacs africains, ainsi que les questions liées à la justice, aux droits humains, à la gouvernance, aux conflits, à la paix, aux réfugiés, aux ressources naturelles et à la responsabilité publique en Afrique.

Nous accueillons également les annonces concernant de nouvelles ou d'anciennes publications liées à nos domaines d'intérêt. Vous pouvez annoncer gratuitement votre publication, notamment un livre, un rapport, une étude, un article académique ou tout autre travail pertinent.

Les articles doivent être rédigés en anglais ou en français et ne doivent pas dépasser 1 500 mots.

Veuillez inclure le nom complet de l'auteur, qui sera publié avec l'article s'il est accepté.

Avant de soumettre votre article, veuillez d'abord lire nos pages du site web afin de vérifier si votre article correspond à nos priorités éditoriales, à nos thèmes et à nos domaines d'intérêt.

Si vous avez un article, un commentaire ou une annonce de publication à partager avec un public plus large, veuillez l'envoyer par email à :

africarealitiesmedia@gmail.com

Nous étudierons la possibilité de publier gratuitement les articles et annonces de publications appropriés s'ils répondent à nos critères éditoriaux, notamment la pertinence, la clarté, l'originalité, l'intérêt public, le respect des communautés concernées et l'utilisation responsable des informations et des preuves.

Les articles sont publiés tels qu'ils sont soumis s'ils répondent à nos critères et à notre politique éditoriale. Nous ne procédons pas à une modification supplémentaire de votre article avant sa publication.