[AfricaRealities.com] ON RWANDA’S PRESIDENTIAL TERMS LIMIT IN THE 2003 RWANDAN CONSTITUTION AS AMENDED

A referendum to amend Article 101 of the Rwandan Constitution would be illegal and null. Article 101 of the Rwandan Constitution cannot be amended by a referendum because such a referendum would amount to "circumstance," yet Article 101 provides that "under no circumstance …" can the Article 101 provision be modified.

Charles Kambanda posted in Friends of Reason

Charles Kambanda

9:50pm Mar 22

ON RWANDA'S PRESIDENTIAL TERMS LIMIT IN THE 2003 RWANDAN CONSTITUTION AS AMENDED:

There is no legal instrument or methods to circumvent the terms limit save for a coup which would suspend or abrogate the Rwandan Constitution in its entirety.

A systematic move to drop presidential terms limit, to allow the incumbent to run for the same office after his two constitutional terms expire in 2017, is gaining momentum in Rwanda. Top Kagame regime officials are on a crusade to popularize their plan to drop term limit from the constitution. No Rwandan but current President Paul Kagame, they argue, is capable of leading the country. It appears that the Kagame regime wants to give the world the idea that "the people" are begging Kagame to stay in power, contrary to what "the people" have already said under Article 101 of the Rwandan Constitution.

Wrong argument and motive:

The gist of the Kagame regime's argument is that "the people" have powers to change any provision of the constitution at any time they believe a provision or a combination of provisions in the constitution has been overtaken by events. The common stanza in Kagame's camp is that no Rwandan is capable of leading the country; Kagame cannot go just because the constitution dictates he must. The constitution must therefore be amended to keep Kagame in the country's top office. It appears to me that the top office is Kagame's shield from prosecution for crimes in Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), which have been alleged in international courts. It is evident that the Presidency is to President Kagame what water is for fish. He will probably stop at nothing to hold on to power as long as it's possible for him. In any case, he took power by the gun, he rules by the gun.

Strategy to amend the Rwandan Constitution:
Article 101 of the Rwandan Constitution provides that, "The President of the Republic is elected for a term of seven years, renewable only once. Under no circumstances shall a person hold the office of President of Republic for more than two terms."

This constitutional provision is categorical on three major points:

(a) No circumstance – external or internal, political or social, present or future by any institution or individual - may be the basis for allowing any person to be president if that person has served two terms. Clearly stated, no amendment to this provision is possible as such grounds for such amendment would amount to circumstances that are certainly prohibited by the "under no circumstance" clause of Article 101.

(b) Whether one serves two presidential terms uninterrupted or interrupted, two terms is the cut-off point; no person can hold that office beyond two terms under the 2003 Rwandan Constitution.

(c) Serving more than two terms is as prohibited, as is amending Article 101 on terms limit. Consequently, as long as the 2003 constitution is in force, no circumstance – including "the people's" zeal to keep Kagame is permitted to modify this provision.

Article 101 cannot be amended under Article 193 of Rwandan Constitution:

Article 193 provides that "The power to initiate amendment of the Constitution is vested concurrently in the President of the Republic upon the proposal of the Cabinet and each Chamber of Parliament upon a resolution passed by a two thirds majority vote of its members. The passage of a constitutional amendment requires a three quarters majority vote of the members of each chamber of Parliament. However, if the constitutional amendment concerns the term of the President of the Republic or the system of democratic government based on political pluralism, or the constitutional regime established by this Constitution especially the republican form of the government or national sovereignty, the amendment must be passed by referendum, after adoption by each Chamber of Parliament…" Apparently, Kagame regime wrongly believes that the constitution amendment procedure under Article 193 including a referendum applies to Article 101 on presidential terms limit.

Articles 101 and 193 of Rwandan constitution are distinguishable:

First, whereas under Article 193, the President and Parliament may initiate an amendment to the constitution, Article 101 "under no circumstance" clause prevents the President or Parliament to initiate amendment to Article 101 because any reasons and/or circumstances for such amendment would trigger Article 101 "under no circumstances …" clause.

Second, whereas Article 193 provides for amendment of other provisions of the constitution for the constitution to adopt to changing circumstances, using any circumstance thereof would be inconsistent with Article 101 " under no circumstance …" clause. Consequently, any law that seeks to amend Article 101 to reflect changing circumstances (political or social) - to the extent it is inconsistent with Article 101 "under no circumstance" clause - is null and void under Article 200 of the Rwandan Constitution, which provides that "The Constitution is the supreme law of the state. Any law which is contrary to this Constitution is null and void".

Third, while Article 193 of the Rwandan Constitution provides for amendment to the current number of years per presidential term (seven years), Article 101 deals with the number of years one presidential term lasts and the number of terms after which a person cannot hold the Rwanda's top office ( two terms). Therefore, while the number of years each presidential term can last is subject to amendment under Article 193, the number of terms (2 terms) a person can be a president is not subject to change because Article 101 has already sealed the number of terms to two not renewable terms. While Article 193 provides "… if the constitutional amendment concerns the term of the President of the Republic or the system of democratic government based on political pluralism […] the amendment must be passed by referendum, after adoption by each Chamber of Parliament…", Article 101 provides "The President of the Republic is elected for a term of seven years renewable only once. Under no circumstances shall a person hold the office of President of Republic for more than two terms". There is a difference between term (singular) – which refers to the number of years per term and terms (plural) – which refers to the number of terms a person can be a president under Rwanda's constitution. In both Article 101 and Article 193, the word "term" refers to the number of years that constitute a term while the word "terms" in Article 101 refers to the number of terms a person can be president. While Article 193 provides for amendment of presidential term (7 years), the Article is silent about the process to amend presidential "terms" because Article 101 sealed presidential terms off for amendment under the "under no circumstance …" clause.

A referendum to amend Article 101 would be illegal and null:
Article 101 of the Rwandan Constitution cannot be amended by a referendum because such a referendum would amount to "circumstance," yet Article 101 provides that "under no circumstance …" can the Article 101 provision be modified.

A referendum in Rwanda's constitution is provided for to amend, inter alia, the number of years one presidential term can last as provided for under Article 193 "… if the constitutional amendment concerns the term of the President of the Republic or the system of democratic government based on political pluralism, […] the amendment must be passed by referendum, after adoption by each Chamber of Parliament…".

Therefore, whereas the number of years one term of the president can be more than 7 or even less than 7 if that amendment is passed by referendum after adoption by each Chamber, Article 101 is beyond that; not even a referendum would modify Article 101 because "The President of the Republic is elected for [one] term of seven years, renewable only once [and] Under no circumstances shall a person hold the office of President of Republic for more than two terms", as per Article 101 of Rwanda's constitution.

Article 193 of Rwanda's constitution is wrongly cited by Kagame government as the basis for overriding Article 101 which slaps a complete ban on a person's stay in power after serving two terms. There is no inconsistency between Article 101 and Article 193. In any case, the framers of Rwanda's constitution cannot have intended that one Article of the Constitutions invalidates another provision of the constitution. Certainly, the framers of the constitution used "term" and "terms" to mean two different things in Article 101. The fact that the framers of the constitution subjected presidential "term" to amendment under Article 193 without subjecting presidential "terms" to amendment under 193 is revealing; the "under no circumstance …" clause on presidential terms limit is unaffected by the constitutional amendment process under Article 193

Article 101 of Rwanda's constitution cannot be amended. The framers of Rwanda's constitution worded Article 101 in such a way that any reason or circumstance anybody or a group of people might have against the presidential terms limit cannot be used to amend Article 101 because the Article foresaw all those possible "reasons" and circumstances and concluded that "under no circumstance…" and, accordingly, Article 200 puts it clearly that any law or act to tamper with Article 101 or any other provision of the constitution is null and void.

The framers of the 2003 Rwanda constitution sealed off presidential terms limit from amendment probably because Rwandans are aware of the dangers of one group of people holding on to power indefinitely. Rwandan's political history is characterized by extreme violence and militant rulers loading it over their subjects indefinitely. This has always led to wars and horrific crimes. It's not surprising that the 2003 constitution is unique on presidential terms limit.

###

"Hate Cannot Drive Out Hate. Only Love Can Do That", Dr. Martin Luther King.

__._,_.___

Posted by: Nzinink <nzinink@yahoo.com>

Reply via web post

•

Reply to sender

•

Reply to group

•

Start a New Topic

•

Messages in this topic (1)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish.
I have loved justice and hated iniquity: therefore I die in exile.
The price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men.
When the white man came we had the land and they had the bibles; now they have the land and we have the bibles.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Voice of the Poor, the Weak and Powerless.

-----------------------------------------------------------
Post message: AfricaRealities@yahoogroups.com
Subscribe: AfricaRealities-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
Unsubscribe: AfricaRealities-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
List owner: AfricaRealities-owner@yahoogroups.com
__________________________________________________________________

Please consider the environment before printing this email or any attachments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-http://www.africarealities.com/

-https://www.facebook.com/africarealities

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-New International Scholarships opportunities: http://www.scholarshipsgate.com
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Visit Your Group

• Privacy • Unsubscribe • Terms of Use

__,_._,___

Comments

Africa Realities Media offre un espace aux écrivains, chercheurs, experts, activistes, voix communautaires, militants, analystes et personnes ayant une expérience vécue qui souhaitent contribuer à des contenus réfléchis, responsables et courageux sur les changements nécessaires dans la région des Grands Lacs, ainsi que sur les réalités politiques, économiques, culturelles et sociales africaines souvent ignorées, minimisées ou mal représentées. Nos articles et vidéos visent à ouvrir le débat, renforcer la sensibilisation, encourager la pensée critique et favoriser une réflexion plus profonde sur les réalités vécues par les populations africaines. Nous voulons aider les peuples de la région des Grands Lacs à mieux comprendre leurs droits, notamment leurs droits humains, leur droit au développement, leur droit à la dignité, à la sécurité, au bien-être et à une vie meilleure. À travers nos contenus, nous cherchons également à rappeler aux décideurs, aux institutions publiques, aux acteurs régionaux et internationaux, ainsi qu’aux responsables politiques, leur devoir de transparence, de responsabilité et de redevabilité envers les populations qu’ils prétendent servir. Notre objectif est de contribuer à une culture de vérité, de justice, de participation citoyenne et de protection égale pour tous les peuples africains.

Why Africa Realities Media Is Different

Africa Realities Media speaks to Africa and to the developed world. Many abuses facing African people are committed by African states and ruling elites, but they are often protected by international silence, lobbying, public relations, trade interests, migration deals and unequal global accountability. While governments pay lobbyists to present a good image abroad, ordinary African people continue to face violence, hunger, disease, poverty, repression and exclusion. We challenge the normalisation of African suffering and demand equal truth, equal justice and equal protection.

Pourquoi Africa Realities Media est différent?

Africa Realities Media s’adresse à l’Afrique et au monde développé. De nombreux abus subis par les peuples africains sont commis par des États africains et des élites dirigeantes, mais ils sont souvent protégés par le silence international, le lobbying, les relations publiques, les intérêts commerciaux, les accords migratoires et une responsabilité mondiale inégale. Tandis que des gouvernements paient des lobbyistes pour présenter une bonne image à l’étranger, des Africains ordinaires continuent de faire face à la violence, à la faim, aux maladies, à la pauvreté, à la répression et à l’exclusion. Nous contestons la normalisation de la souffrance africaine et exigeons une vérité égale, une justice égale et une protection égale.

Exposing Injustice in Africa

Africa Realities Media is an independent African accountability platform based in London. We report, analyse and challenge the systems that shape African suffering, silence African victims and protect abusive power. We are not here to repeat diplomatic language. We are here to ask the questions that are often avoided: why are African deaths treated as normal? Why are African victims given less urgency? Why are governments that imprison, exclude, displace or kill their own people protected when they serve powerful international interests?

Africa Realities Media gives space to writers, researchers, experts, activists, community voices, campaigners, analysts and people with lived experience who want to contribute thoughtful, responsible and courageous content about the changes needed in the region, as well as the political, economic, cultural and social African realities that are often ignored, minimised or misrepresented. Our articles and videos aim to encourage debate, raise awareness, stimulate critical thinking and support reflection. We seek to help people in the Great Lakes Region understand their rights to human rights, development and wellbeing, while also encouraging decision-makers to be more transparent, responsive and accountable.

Appel à contributions

Sensibilisez le public aux causes qui vous tiennent à cœur. Prenez part au changement que vous souhaitez voir émerger. Aidez à combattre l'injustice partout où elle se manifeste.

Africa Realities Media accueille des articles originaux, analyses, tribunes, réflexions communautaires et commentaires fondés sur des faits concernant la région des Grands Lacs africains, ainsi que les questions liées à la justice, aux droits humains, à la gouvernance, aux conflits, à la paix, aux réfugiés, aux ressources naturelles et à la responsabilité publique en Afrique.

Nous accueillons également les annonces concernant de nouvelles ou d'anciennes publications liées à nos domaines d'intérêt. Vous pouvez annoncer gratuitement votre publication, notamment un livre, un rapport, une étude, un article académique ou tout autre travail pertinent.

Les articles doivent être rédigés en anglais ou en français et ne doivent pas dépasser 1 500 mots.

Veuillez inclure le nom complet de l'auteur, qui sera publié avec l'article s'il est accepté.

Avant de soumettre votre article, veuillez d'abord lire nos pages du site web afin de vérifier si votre article correspond à nos priorités éditoriales, à nos thèmes et à nos domaines d'intérêt.

Si vous avez un article, un commentaire ou une annonce de publication à partager avec un public plus large, veuillez l'envoyer par email à :

africarealitiesmedia@gmail.com

Nous étudierons la possibilité de publier gratuitement les articles et annonces de publications appropriés s'ils répondent à nos critères éditoriaux, notamment la pertinence, la clarté, l'originalité, l'intérêt public, le respect des communautés concernées et l'utilisation responsable des informations et des preuves.

Les articles sont publiés tels qu'ils sont soumis s'ils répondent à nos critères et à notre politique éditoriale. Nous ne procédons pas à une modification supplémentaire de votre article avant sa publication.

Africa Realities Media | African Human Rights and Accountability

Search This Blog

About Africa Realities Media

Category Posts